You Were the Creative Star. So Why Do You Feel So Stuck Now? | Episode 28

Free Strategy Session: If you want help breaking through creative burnout, grab a free 30-minute strategy call at www.shawnbuttner.com/30 ------- You were the creative star — the ideas, the voice, the energy that made it all happen. But somewhere along the way, success turned your spark into caution. And here’s the truth: caution kills creativity. In this episode, I’ll share why even the most talented creators can get stuck after success and what you can do to reignite your creative fire. I’ll walk you through my own story — how a silly, low-stakes Instagram reel about my coffee routine became the best-performing content I’d ever made, and what it taught me about overthinking, experimentation, and joy in the creative process. You’ll also hear lessons from creators like Jay Klaus, behind-the-scenes insights from Saturday Night Live, and a surprising pottery class study that proves why quantity often beats perfection. From there, I’ll break down five focus shifts that can get you unstuck fast: focus on effort, not outcomes; show up for the work instead of waiting for magic; embrace learning over perfection; think in terms of long-term growth rather than single hits; and choose intrinsic goals over external pressure. We’ll also talk about the balance between strategy and joy, why repeating what works can be useful (until it isn’t), and how to recognize when mental health challenges might be the real creative block. By the end, you’ll have a clear, practical framework for getting back to the kind of work that made you the creative star in the first place — and the confidence to let success follow naturally.