296. Why Do Leaders Fear Being Honest with Their Congregation? with Tom Bennardo, author of Open-Hearted People, Soul-Connected Church

Why is it so hard for pastors and church people to be truly open and honest with one another? In ministry, we talk a lot about authenticity, vulnerability, and grace—but in reality, putting those ideals into practice can feel risky, messy, and even dangerous. In this episode, Tom Bennardo, author of Open-Hearted People, Soul-Connected Church, draws on decades of pastoral experience to unpack the journey from guarded exteriors to soul-connected community, offering practical wisdom for leaders who want to foster deeper spiritual formation and resilience through messy, honest, and grace-filled relationships. THIS EPISODE"S HIGHLIGHTS INCLUDE:Markus Watson introduces the idea that some traditions focus on good behavior as the main thing God desires.Tom Bennardo strongly asserts that God is most interested in our hearts and souls, not primarily our outward behavior.The center of spiritual life is the soul—the inner person—and when our hearts are transformed, right behavior naturally follows.Many people develop performance-based Christianity and need to unlearn legalistic mindsets to embrace grace.Tom Bennardo describes his journey from legalism to understanding grace as central to authentic spiritual formation.The true spiritual transformation flows from inward honesty, authenticity, and a willingness to reveal one"s real self to God and others.Tom Bennardo defines “open heartedness” as direct, honest engagement of one’s soul—with God, oneself, and others.Spiritual growth requires level-three honesty: openly acknowledging the present condition of our soul, not just past mistakes or surface facts.Open hearted living involves being vulnerably honest not only with God, but also with ourselves and select others.Markus Watson suggests that being open hearted in relationship—with self, God, and others—can provoke anxiety, especially regarding sharing with other people.Creating authentic community requires churches to move beyond surface relationships, foster deeper honesty, and cultivate environments where vulnerability is safe and valued.Tom Bennardo highlights the importance of leaders modeling open heartedness before expecting it from congregations.Spiritual leaders must prioritize genuine relationships rather than merely teaching principles from a distance; transformation is “caught as much as taught.”Open heartedness builds resilience in leaders, enabling them to face challenges and change with trust in God rather than rigid control or certainty about the future.Tom Bennardo encourages leaders to pursue a collaborative, open-handed approach, trusting God’s guidance and fostering group discernment rather than solitary authority. RELEVANT RESOURCES AND LINKS:https://tombennardo.com/Books mentioned:Open-hearted People, Soul-Connected Church, by Tom BennardoRelated episodes:262. From Fired to Flourishing, with Chuck DeGroat266. The Church as Shalom Maker, with Terry A. Smith288. Leadership Send me a text! I’d love to know what you're thinking! Get Becoming Leaders of Shalom for free HERE. Click HERE to get my FREE online course, BECOMING LEADERS OF SHALOM.